For Reviewers
Resources and guidelines for conducting peer reviews
Review Process
Invitation
Receive an invitation to review a manuscript in your area of expertise.
Evaluation
Assess the manuscript for originality, methodology, results, and significance.
Feedback
Provide constructive feedback and a recommendation to the editor.
Follow-up
Review revised manuscripts if requested by the editor.
Reviewer Guidelines
Ethical Considerations
- Maintain confidentiality of all manuscript information
- Declare any conflicts of interest
- Provide objective and unbiased evaluations
- Respect the intellectual independence of authors
- Complete reviews within the agreed timeframe
Review Criteria
- Originality and significance of the research
- Appropriateness of methodology and data analysis
- Clarity and organization of the manuscript
- Validity of conclusions based on the results
- Relevance of references and literature review
- Quality of figures, tables, and supplementary materials
Reviewer Resources
Review Templates
Structured templates to help you provide comprehensive and consistent reviews.
Training Materials
Resources to enhance your reviewing skills and knowledge.
Support
Get help with the review process and system.
Reviewer Recognition
We value the essential contribution of our reviewers to the academic publishing process. To recognize your efforts, we offer:
Certificates
Annual certificates of recognition for active reviewers.
Publons Integration
Track and verify your reviewing contributions.
Editorial Board Consideration
Outstanding reviewers may be invited to join editorial boards.